Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-15 Green Mountain Diapers 0 views

Give It A Try Kit vs Try Both Kit: Medium Cloth Diaper Comparison

Give It A Try Kit vs Try Both Kit: Medium Cloth Diaper Comparison

Both medium trial kits fit around 14 pounds, but one includes 12 changes with prefolds and fitteds while the other packs 6 fitted diapers and 2 covers. Compare contents, fit, and prep.

Two medium kits, two different trial approaches

The Give It A Try Kit - Medium and the Try Both Kit - Medium both start at about 14 pounds, but they answer different questions. One lets you test a single diapering style with a small number of changes; the other lets you compare two absorbent options side by side over a dozen changes. Your choice depends on whether you already know you like fitted diapers or want to decide between fitteds and prefolds.

What each kit contains

  • Give It A Try Kit - Medium: 6 Workhorse Fitted Diapers Snap closure in size Medium (14–24 lb), 2 Thirsties Duo Wraps snap closure size two (18–40 lb, though the brand notes it runs smaller, more like 15 to about 29–30 lb), and 1 pack of 12 Cloth-eez Birdseye Wipes in natural unbleached. That is 6 changes, all fitted diapers.
  • Try Both Kit - Medium: 6 Cloth-eez Prefolds size medium, 6 Cloth-eez Workhorse Diapers size Medium, 3 Thirsties Duo Wrap Snaps size Two, and 1 pair of GMD Slide Lock Pins. That is 12 changes total, split evenly between prefolds and fitteds.

Fit range: where each kit stops working

Both kits list a starting weight of about 14 pounds for the diapers, but the covers and absorbent pieces have different upper limits. In the Try Both Kit, the Workhorse diapers in medium will be outgrown before the prefolds and covers, which continue to fit to about 28 pounds. The Give It A Try Kit uses the same Workhorse medium diapers (14–24 lb) and Thirsties Duo Wraps size two, which the brand says fit roughly 15 to 29–30 pounds. So the fitted diapers are the limiting factor in both kits, and the Try Both Kit gives you prefolds that can keep working after the fitteds are too small.

Sizing facts that affect how long each kit lasts

  • Give It A Try Kit - Medium: Workhorse Fitted Diapers in size Medium fit 14–24 pounds; Thirsties Duo Wraps size two are listed as 18–40 pounds but the brand notes they run smaller, more like 15 to about 29–30 pounds. If your baby is near the top of the fitted diaper range, you may get more months of use from the prefolds in the Try Both Kit than from the fitteds in either kit.
    Give It A Try Kit - Medium
    Give It A Try Kit - Medium
  • Try Both Kit - Medium: The Try Both Kit includes 6 medium prefolds and 6 medium Workhorse diapers, plus 3 Thirsties Duo Wrap Snaps size Two. The Workhorse will be outgrown before the prefolds and covers, which continue to fit to about 28 pounds. This kit lets you test prefolds, which have a longer potential fit range, alongside fitteds, so you can decide which system to build on.
    Try Both Kit - Medium
    Try Both Kit - Medium

How many changes you get and what that means for trial

The Give It A Try Kit gives you 6 changes with fitted diapers and 2 covers. The Try Both Kit gives you 12 changes (6 prefolds and 6 fitteds) and 3 covers. If your goal is to test whether cloth diapering fits your routine at all, 6 changes may be enough to try a day or two. If you want to compare absorbency, trimness, or ease of use between prefolds and fitteds, the Try Both Kit provides a more direct side-by-side test. Keep in mind that covers can usually be reused through several changes—change the inner absorbency part and put the same cover back on for a few changes, or alternate between 2 covers—so the number of covers is less critical than the number of absorbent pieces.

Preparation and care differences

The Give It A Try Kit includes unbleached natural cotton, which needs several initial wash cycles to wash off natural cotton oils before first use. That is a one-time step. The Try Both Kit includes both prefolds and Workhorse diapers in natural unbleached cotton, so you can expect a similar prep routine for those absorbent pieces. The product information for the Try Both Kit does not list a specific number of prep washes, so follow the general guidance for unbleached cotton. For covers, the Try Both Kit notes that covers dry quickly and can be washed out when you wash your hands if you need to freshen one before laundry day.

Cost and value: what the price difference buys

At catalog prices, the Give It A Try Kit - Medium is $90.49 (compared to a $127.45 comparison price), and the Try Both Kit - Medium is $106.13 (compared to $158.40). The Try Both Kit costs more but includes double the changes (12 vs 6), an extra cover, and the chance to test two diaper styles. If you are already confident you want fitted diapers, the Give It A Try Kit is a lower-cost entry point. If you are undecided between prefolds and fitteds, the Try Both Kit may save you from buying a separate prefold trial later.

Which kit fits your diapering plan?

Choose the Give It A Try Kit - Medium if you want a simple, all-fitted trial with fewer pieces and a lower upfront cost, and you are comfortable with the 14–24 pound fitted range. Choose the Try Both Kit - Medium if you want to compare prefolds and fitteds directly, need more changes before laundry day, or want the longer fit potential of prefolds (up to about 28 pounds) alongside the fitteds. Neither kit includes a one-size system; both are sized for the medium range, so check your baby's current weight and expected growth before ordering.

Product facts for the two medium kits

  • Give It A Try Kit - Medium: Give It A Try Kit - Medium includes 6 Workhorse Fitted Diapers Snap closure (size Medium 14–24 lb), 2 Thirsties Duo Wraps snap closure size two, and 1 pack of 12 Cloth-eez Birdseye Wipes in natural unbleached. This is a complete fitted-diaper trial with wipes included, suitable for someone who wants to try one style with minimal extras.
  • Try Both Kit - Medium: Try Both Kit - Medium includes 6 Cloth-eez Prefolds size medium, 6 Cloth-eez Workhorse Diapers size Medium, 3 Thirsties Duo Wrap Snaps size Two, and 1 pair of GMD Slide Lock Pins, for 12 diaper changes. This kit provides a direct comparison of prefolds and fitteds, plus pins for prefold closure, and more changes before washing.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile